r/XboxSeriesX Nov 20 '23

Starfield is still being worked on by 250 Bethesda devs Discussion

https://www.pcgamesn.com/starfield/bethesda-team
1.8k Upvotes

763 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-15

u/UnHoly_One Nov 20 '23

User reviews aren’t worth the bandwidth you use reading them.

11

u/AuthoritarianSex Nov 20 '23

Could the same not be said for critic reviews? Do they even review a game below a 7/10 these days unless it’s like irredeemably bad? Review publishers don’t want to lose out on early copies and basically hand out 8’s and above like candy

5

u/UnHoly_One Nov 20 '23

You are correct, they suck too.

But they aren’t brought down by people buying the game with the express purpose of rating it 1/10 then refunding it.

9

u/AuthoritarianSex Nov 20 '23

I totally agree that there are a lot of garbage user reviews. Still doesn’t change the fact that Starfield has mixed reviews. There are Bethesda games that are positively rated. Cyberpunk had a much bigger hate campaign against it and still has very positive reviews.

There’s a reason the reviews for Starfield are the way they are now

-6

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

Cyberpunk had a much bigger hate campaign against it

you dont actually believe this right?

lmao imagine taking user reviews seriously

5

u/JohnnyChutzpah Nov 20 '23

You should look at the some of the games that have overwhelmingly positive reviews on steam. They are the ones that aren’t highly mediocre or bad.

Steam has a solid review system and steam tags reviews as refunded for people who refunded the game. Also shows their playtime. And people can vote and award reviews.

Xbox, however, does have a horribly broken joke of a review system.

0

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

just read a review on steam that said

"5 out 10 can't give a game angry joe said was bad a good review"

ya man totally legit

4

u/JohnnyChutzpah Nov 20 '23

Cool. I bet the other 10s of thousands of reviews fit your bias as well and are not, you know, a reflection of reality.

It’s a mediocre game. I played it. 5/10 is a solid score for it. I played it before reading any reviews and still would have given it a 5/10.

-1

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

its a fantastic game, as most of the actual reviews have stated

probably the 2nd best so far this generation

" not on Playstation 1 out 10" lol

3

u/AuthoritarianSex Nov 20 '23

2nd best game of this generation and it didn’t even crack a nomination for GOTY? Lmao. There’s debate over whether this was even the best xbox game this year

1

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

there are game awards?

like the grammys? lmao what the fuck

1

u/AuthoritarianSex Nov 20 '23

Yeah and it’s pretty telling Starfield didn’t even get a nomination, great single player games have always been nominated

1

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

oh no

now i dont like starfield anymore

→ More replies (0)

5

u/JohnnyChutzpah Nov 20 '23

You are allowed to like it. But it’s a janky disjointed mess running on dated systems not able to handle the vision they had for the game. It’s an objectively mediocre game.

-1

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

lol

the irrational hatred for this game from a certain group is wild, im sure it comes from a place of no bias

5

u/JohnnyChutzpah Nov 20 '23

I don’t hate the game. I’m glad people are having fun. I’m just disappointed I can’t have fun, and people keep gaslighting me into thinking it’s a great game.

https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198089168523/recommended/1716740/

There is the top review on steam. 100 hours played. No refund. 1700 upvotes. Not a word about PlayStation or angry Joe. You are denying reality.

1

u/80sCrackBaby Nov 20 '23

thankfully in objective reality

the game did fantastically well made Microsoft alot of money and owned the mindshare for the last few months

feel how you will i guess lol

→ More replies (0)