r/therewasanattempt 5d ago

To steal another person's property

Post image
24.9k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

7.5k

u/SlowDownHotSauce 5d ago

PSA: Booby trapping is EXTREMELY illegal. The injured person WILL win a civil suit against you. No, it does not matter that they were stealing or trespassing.

Source: Law School Torts class. The only other civil case that is easier to win is when someone defiles or abuses a dead body.

22

u/mr_lamp 5d ago

Could I give permission for someone to cut off a toe after I die to save in a jar or is that still illegal?

15

u/SlowDownHotSauce 5d ago

not legal advice - but I believe most jurisdictions require bio-waste (like body parts) to be disposed of in specific ways to avoid the spread of diseases. So most likely no, you wouldn’t be able to do that. Unless you were maybe donating your body to science or something like that. Even then, the person/entity you were donating to would likely need to have some sort of permission from the local authorities to be keeping bodily remains.

8

u/SirGirthfrmDickshire 5d ago

If you're going in for surgery you can actually request to keep the body part that's getting removed. As for someone else's body part I believe there has to be written permission and the signature of the person that died to do so. Like in a will.

9

u/Sothdargaard 5d ago

Probably depends on location. I work in the OR and in every state I've worked in (only 5 so far) you can clean implants (like screws, rods, etc.) and give those to the patient. You absolutely cannot give body parts to them even if they want it.

2

u/ZhouLe 4d ago

I imagine there are some very tight hoops to release parts to people; e.g. religious exemptions, must be released to a funeral home or crematory, etc. I have to think it could be a quagmire if a hospital amputates the leg of someone of certain religious sects and refuses to accommodate burial of those remains.

1

u/SirGirthfrmDickshire 4d ago

Unless things have changed in the last 6 years this video explains about it, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2EpDQ53zb3Q

1

u/FinancialLight1777 5d ago

Damn man, I feel awkward asking my mechanic for the old parts back, let alone my surgeon.

9

u/HowDoIEvenEnglish 5d ago

Human remains are highly regulated and a will isn’t enough most of the time

2

u/the_art_of_the_taco Free Palestine 5d ago

Mummify it and send it to the Yukon so folks can season their whiskey.

1

u/Mr-Fleshcage 4d ago

That one guy will just swallow it again

1

u/Recyart 4d ago

Depends on whose toe.

1

u/CrossP 4d ago

If you're in the US, that one will depend on the state. Different states have different laws regarding exactly how a corpse must be handled.